Sunday, September 30, 2007

IPhone review

d3xlabs - Hi everyone, allow me to introduce to you, a review by a good buddy of mine, my guest blogger... with the Apple iPhone review. Enjoy...


There're already tonnes of iPhone reviews on the net so I'm just going to stick with the more personal experiences. (For a really indepth review, look at arstechnica). Do keep in mind as you're reading this, I've become much of a mac buff since I picked up a black macbook about a year ago.

The usual suspects

Stacked against Treo, Nokia and Ipods
First off, this thing is thin! It feels like a well crafted luxury item (say, like a Rolex?). Seamless and perfect cuts round each corner. Its something you can't appreciate until you hold it in your own hands. The metal and glass mix really takes the device to another level, downgrading every other plastic phone you've held. Needless to say, it passes the "twist" creak test and makes you feel silly you even tried. It LOOKS fragile, but in your hands, it feels like it can really take a beating. The week as gone by without a case, and not a blemish to be found. I'm not planning to get a case.

Work of art
Unlike a Treo, it slips discretely into your pocket so you can forget about as you go about your daily routine. Comfortable in jeans. That's something hugely refreshing being a Treo user for 3 years. You'd also know by now that the back of the phone is a matte metal, a welcome change to the scratch magnet that the iPods are. The weight feels just nice.

Polished vs Matte
Software
Much like switching to the Mac, the first few days can drive you a little nuts. (If you're never tried a Mac, walk into AV and mess with an iMac for a while.) Everything works a little differently, and sometimes, its frustrating because you don't know how to do the simplest of tasks.
Right off, you'll notice it takes more steps to do phone stuff.

For instance, to place a call on the iPhone:
  1. Turn on phone
  2. Slide to unlock
  3. Press Home button
  4. Touch Phone icon
  5. Touch Contacts or Favorites
  6. Scroll to Contact (arranged by last name)
  7. Select Contact Name
  8. Touch phone number to dial
On the Treo:
  1. Press power
  2. Press Center key to Unlock
  3. Type Contact initials
  4. Select the Contact to Dial
Woah. 8 steps. Though, Apple makes sure that each of those 8 steps are as sensuously delicious as going through phone menus can possibly be. Going into the 4th or 5th day, I'm still amused by the detail they put into the graphics and animation. Elegantly done.
For the most part, you'll find that tasks are quickly and easily done.


Phone
Reception is on par with a Treo, which is a little worse than a Nokia. Voice quality is above average, clear and pronounced even in noisy environments. The interface is basic but straight forward and easy to navigate. Place speed dials in "Favorites" and you're set to go.


Brunei: SMS Nation
I can't live without threaded SMS chat. If you're still using Inbox style SMS, you're really missing out. iPhone pulls off SMS chats beautifully. Its easy to scroll back through the conversation. My only disappointment is that you can't delete individual messages. You'll have to delete the entire thread. Not a problem MOST of the time. If you have someone send you a password or some ugly sms chain text picture thingies, you can't individually delete them and keep the other messages. Annoying.

Oh, and no Character count! With $0.03 sms's, it doesn't bother me much. But I know it'll bother some of you.

While I'm in this topic, I might as well talk about the keyboard. All the other reviewers weren't lying. Google "Iphone review keyboard", and they all say you get used to the keyboard after a while. Not as good as a physical thumbboard, but not far off. Don't let first impressions fool you, and trust the Autocorrect.
Two handed (or thumbed) typing is easy, although the standard index finger hunt and peck is more precise. Both styles work and are fast enough.


Killer App
Steve Jobs is wrong. The killer app in the iPhone isn't the Phone. It's the Photo viewer, the perfect extension to iPhoto (on the Mac). Just as with any iPod, iTunes will optimise the the pictures before uploading it into the device. Its strange. The experience is fresh, yet, nostalgic. Its like flipping through the printed 4R photo albums of old, except digitally.
Doing the reverse "pinch" to zoom in is the No.1 show off factor.

Its lengthy to describe in words so check out this movie in apple.com

The Party in "Third Party"
The good news is that in Brunei, you'll be sporting an Unlocked iPhone. This means you'll have access to the 'Installer' app. This will appear as the 13th icon in your virgin iPhone. Open it up and it lists hundreds of 3rd party items you can download directly in Installer and load it up. I recommend to install Summerboard as your first stop. This allows you to scroll in the main menu and choose from a flurry of themes. My current fav is "Space" as seen below. The pics in the preview post d3xlabs put up are using the "Tiger Basic" theme.

Tiger Basic - side by side with the original menu
Space theme
Son of iPod
Best iPod ever? I'd say, Yes. I'm no audiophile, but music sounds as good as on my 5.5G iPod. Browsing my music and podcasts is easier, and coverflow is lots of fun. I'm more inclined to scroll through some older music I've neglected. I have to re-encode some divx movies to put them on, but they turned out absolutely gorgeous!


Transformers 2007 (Full Length - 1GB) encoded in H.264
Check out music on the iPhone.

The Real Internet
Apart from the fact that there's no Flash and Java (which is different from javascript), Safari works incredibly well! Brudirect loads up just fine, and easily navigated. Wifi has never been so useful. ApolloIM fills the gap if you get on MSN or Yahoo. Its still an early build, but lots of potential.
Email, on the other hand, just scrapes by. It works. Having used push email, I feel cheated, but I'll survive.
Brudirect

Others
Camera is nothing spectacular. The 2MP cam is a lot better than Treo, and probably on par with standard Nokias, Motorolas and Samsungs out there. Great pics as long as you have good strong lighting.

Games are sparse, but we have NES, Sudoku, Blackjack and Minesweeper for a start. Bejeweled can be loaded off the internet. This are can only get better.

The stock calendar app does the job. Simple. In my experience, the simpler your time manager, the more likely you'll use it.

Youtube and Googlemaps have never been so good on the phone if you're on wifi. They're completely useless with the slow GPRS/EDGE speeds on DST.

Conclusion
Am I happy? Yes.

But I wouldn't recommend to Treo or other smartphone users. The iPhone, like the Mac, is good with "life" stuff, and just passable for business use. There's no way to save or edit Office documents (only view via email or web). Its hard to scroll through more than 500 contacts. There's no push email (no Exchange or Blackberry support). And limited sync with Outlook.

In brief, its the smartphone for casual users. I believe that is how Apple designed it, and they did a pretty darn good job. If you carry an iPod on a daily basis (like me), I recommend it whole heartedly. Otherwise, it falls in the 'worth a good look' section.

Feel free to post comments/questions, and I'll answer them as best I can.

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

totally agree with you. been using the iphone for a little over a week now and its been a joy to use.

just wanted to ask which program you use to re-encode divx files for ur iphone?

Unknown said...

I highly recommend using VisualHub for reencoding divx. My original Transformers movie was in two parts as well, it stitches the files after encoding and pushes it straight into iTunes.
Sync and I'm done. Looks absolutely stunning on the iPhone.

I was converting it unsuccessfully using quicktime pro, which has an audio lag.

anakbrunei said...

Great review J, you probably put the phone more through its paces than I did hehe! Its a stunning piece of work for sure! I wonder when apple's gonna work on a dSLR ehheh!

Unknown said...

yeap. Its a great device! honestly one of the most exciting phones in a while, that changes the usage paradigm. If Apple decides to eventually open it up, it'll probably gain momentum.
I have to say though, its catered more to the American market than European and Asian market. Generally, we demand more features on the phone.

haha.. yea a DSLR from Apple will be something for sure...!

charmed said...

I dunno....like sensei d3x says "I'm not convinced". It's very pretty though! All girls like big shiny things but after having fiddled with it I'm not so much a fan.

An apple DSLR would be interesting. Maybe no need flash since it's shiny bits will be able to reflect enough light?

Unknown said...

If you're NOT very into the business phone thing, its worth considering. I'm still learning new things about the iPhone which I appreciate such as how the screen blanks out when you hold it to your ear. And the volume changes depending if you plug in your earphone. (i.e it might be at 80% volume, but automatically switches to 40% when you plug in the headset). The earphones are really nice as well. Very discrete. i normally feel like a dork when I wear headsets. Which ipod earphones, not too bad.

Another great thing is not worrying about the phone crashing. Safari does crash, but it just throws you back to the Home menu right away, and not just freeze up.

But ultimately, its about enjoying your media. If you like being able to show photos and videos.... this thing is second to none. Stunning. If you're near wifi, its really a great internet browser.. I can surfing on the thing for quite a bit.
For MSN, it does the job.

Its by no means the SUPER phone that does everything, but all in all it lets you enjoy the experience...
I feel like how I felt when I had the Treo 600... lots of potential, but still 1st generation, so its still a bit of an acquired taste.... Takes time to 'grow' into. If apple hits the right features on the next upgrade, it'll be more mass market.

Anonymous said...

dexxy i want one but some says it has bug n stuff..n still not the complete version is it true.
or its all just a fuss!! aneways..i gerenti it still cant beat an e61i ryte!! ha2..neways hit me back aytes!

d3xlabs said...

violet nox.. hey! How u been? U knw I knw la pasal e61i. I would advise wait for official release of iPhone. Its always being upgraded.

I miss the e61i. LOL.

Anonymous said...

http://markonzo.edu http://www.netknowledgenow.com/members/Adderall-Side-Effects.aspx http://riderx.info/members/allegra-side-effects-allegra.aspx rehouse subregions http://www.netknowledgenow.com/members/Ventolin-inh.aspx http://www.ecometro.com/Community/members/sibutramine-weight-loss.aspx http://riderx.info/members/altace-information-altace-lowest-price.aspx mails http://www.netknowledgenow.com/members/effexor-side-effects.aspx http://www.netknowledgenow.com/members/Cephalexin-500mg.aspx